Worldcoin News: Vitalik Buterin Points Out Key Concerns in Worldcoin’s Approach

Ethereum’s co-founder Vitalik Buterin has revealed some major issues surrounding Worldcoin’s novel identity verification system, which recently launched its WLD token. Buterin’s critique focused on four main areas of potential risk in Worldcoin’s Proof-of-Personhood (PoP) model, and proposes an alternative solution to mitigate these issues.

The PoP Model of Worldcoin

Worldcoin employs a biometric-based PoP system that validates the uniqueness of a user in a decentralized manner, thereby eliminating the need for a centralized authority and minimizing the revelation of personal data. Notable applications of this system include safeguarding against Sybil attacks by inhibiting multiple account creation, airdrops, event ticketing, and DAO voting. The process involves iris scanning by a device named “Orb,” which subsequently verifies a user’s humanity and the uniqueness of the iris to create a unique World ID.

Buterin’s Insights on the Risks of Worldcoin PoP Construction 

Buterin’s scrutiny of the PoP system highlighted four primary risks: privacy, accessibility, centralization, and security.

Privacy

Despite the hashing of iris scans and the use of ZK-SNARKs and other cryptographic methods for user identity protection, Buterin expressed concerns about the misuse or potential leak of identity-related information. He pointed out the possibility of an individual’s iris scan being cross-referenced against the database to determine the existence of a World ID.

Accessibility

The accessibility of Worldcoin’s Orb device is another issue. Buterin believes that the necessity for physical access to an Orb may limit the project’s reach, creating a distribution imbalance favoring areas with a higher concentration of Orbs.

Centralization

Centralization is another area of concern. Buterin argues that the integrity of Orb’s hardware cannot be independently verified, which raises the possibility of backdoors and fake identities. Although Worldcoin intends to decentralize over time, Buterin notes the proprietary algorithms and governance structure as points of centralization concern.

Security

Buterin also called attention to security risks such as phone hacking, ID selling or renting, and the use of 3D-printed “fake people” to trick the system.

Despite these identified risks, Buterin acknowledged the value of the concept behind Worldcoin, and the potential risks of not having any proof-of-personhood systems at all.

Buterin’s Suggestion

Buterin posits that merging the three existing PoP approaches—social-graph-based, general-hardware biometric, and specialized-hardware biometric techniques—could provide a secure, scalable, and privacy-conscious system that offers robust protection against fake identities. This comprehensive solution could potentially address the risks associated with Worldcoin’s approach.

Bottom Line

The launch of Worldcoin marked a significant event in the crypto world. However, Vitalik Buterin’s critique brings attention to the potential pitfalls of its PoP model. It will be interesting to see how these issues are addressed as Worldcoin attempts to revolutionize digital identity verification through blockchain technology.

What are BTCC’s specs?

Sometimes, users feel more comfortable working with an exchange if they know that the exchange has a footprint in the industry. With 12 years of stable and secure operating history, BTCC is one of the top cryptocurrency derivatives exchanges in CoinMarketCap, which boasts a wide selection of 60+ cryptocurrencies and millions of registered users, offering services in 100+ countries.

BTCC charges 0.06% for both takers and makers, which are way below the industry average. According to the largest and most recent empirical study on crypto exchange trading fees, the average spot trading taker fee is 0.2294% and the maker fee is 0.1854%.

With high liquidity, low trading fees and fast transaction speed, BTCC allows users to open a trade immediately even when the crypto markets experience a sharp rise or plunge.

Apart from crypto trading, BTCC also supports tokenized futures service, allowing users to trade stocks and commodities futures (Gold/Silver) with USDT as the margin. The maximum leverage is up to 150x.

Trading on BTCC begins with registration and log in, which only takes 30 seconds. New customers can now sign up here to get a welcome bonus of 10 USDT, and complete the KYC verification to access all BTCC’s features and BTCC bonus. Once verified, you can start trading now.